« Home | Mohammad Image- Every Paper Should Print It » | Road Trip to Derry And Belfast » | 1993: Visit to Belfast » | Baby Found Floating in Lagoon in Brazil » | Roseanne Cash Interview » | Hamas - Suicide Bombers Voted Into Office » | Back to New York » | Off to Florida / Yahoo » | Canada Goes Conservative » | Podcasts / The Kid From Brooklyn »
Posted by The Phantom on Friday, February 03, 2006 at 10:25 PM | Permalink
Female. Either mother or sweetheart. See DANNY BOY: The Beloved Irish Ballad by Malachy McCourt (reviewed here)for a full discussion of the song.
Posted by AMcD |
February 03, 2006 11:13 PM
I wouldn't be sure that this settles it. The review states that McCourt's book has a lot of blarney in it, and it states that even he explores a few theories as to whom the singer might be and who the subject might be.I actually spent many an hour listening to Malachy McCourt, who once had a call-in radio show on what was once a good talk radio station in NYC, WMCA.Malachy was interesting to listen to, but absolutely full of " blarney " when speaking of almost anything. There were howlers on every show. See the original post on Majikthise, there have been good responses there.
Posted by The Phantom |
February 04, 2006 11:14 AM
I think that it is Danny boy's father, an old man. That is why it talks about him possibly being in the grave when Danny come home.I sued to think that it was a sweetheart, but wondered why she thought that SHE might well be dead. It makes more sence as an old man lamenting his son going off to war.
Posted by Aileen |
February 04, 2006 12:29 PM
I feel very strongly that it is a parent that is singig it to a child who is going off to war (which is why the pipes are calling him), someone older who well may be likely to die prior the child's arrival back at home. Found a site that has extensive history, including the facts that the man who wrote the words was a professional English songwriter, who had a son named Danny:http://www.standingstones.com/danny3.html#true
Posted by crabbylady |
February 04, 2006 2:12 PM
After rereading the lyrics, I think you're right that they're gender neutral. Phantom, do you remember Johnny Cash's intro to Danny Boy? It was originally recorded in 1963 and it now appears on the Bear Family "Man in Black" box set. That was where I got the idea that "Danny Boy" had a female narrator. Cash says that the song is about a girl who has to go into the peat bogs and tell her lover that the pipes are calling him off to war. I now think the song had deliberately unisex lyrics, but it's interesting that Cash didn't read them that way.
Posted by Lindsay Beyerstein |
February 04, 2006 3:28 PM
--Do you remember Johnny Cash's intro to Danny Boy?--No! But that is an interesting bit of detail. I will track it down, thanks.I don't know if there's a song that's ever been sung that is more sadly beautiful.Looking at Wikipedia, I see that it was a song that Elvis Presley loved, one which he recorded when he was young and strong, and which was sung at his funeral.I've just found the Elvis rendition of the song on my Yahoo Music Player. God, it's good.Thanks for raising this subject!
Posted by The Phantom |
February 04, 2006 4:12 PM
Create a Link